cracks continue to appear?
20080820I’d like to be able to link the Liu Xiang story to a broader trend about young people in China sacrificing their livelihoods / sanity for the national cause - but I don’t think that’s true. Most of them seem to be doing it because they want to drive a large car and have outlandish luxuries, like their own house.
The takeaway I had while watching the event unfold was one of alienation quickly turned to admiration - someone who finally had the courage to say ‘no.’ That he withdrew as a result of an injury does take some steam out of my sentiment. That may not matter - the general reaction (so far as I’ve interacted with people) seems to be that ‘the pressure was too great,’ and ‘psychological stress can easily lead to physical injury.’
But no one [here] yet seems to have expressed concern at how quickly the state (not even one of the media outlets or state industries, but Vice president of China himself) quickly ‘authorized’ his injury (that they had no way to control it at that point is a meaningless aside, the attempt at maintaining legitimacy was clear).
Contrary to media reports, most of the spectators in the stadium at that time were at first simply confused. Those sitting near us began quickly speaking to eachother, asking what was going on? Was it a stunt? The “silence” that descended was another product of their rapidly spun narrative. What’s most interesting is not that they try to maintain control - everyone here knows that; but rather that the power of story can compel willful ignorance.
What I fear most is that my criticism results only for their being so unsophisticated with these methods. What I find most hopeful is that so many people are questioning.
